Sunday, June 15, 2014
Marcus Borg: Jesus, Uncovering the life Teachings, Relevance of a Religious Revolutionary
I've been slowly reading "Jesus, Uncovering the life Teachings, Relevance of a Religious Revolutionary" and I've been sum what surprised at the strength of Borg's emphasis about the "political-dominance" and how it implicates especially my understanding of the 'Kingdom of God'.
I suppose a crude way of understanding the 'political dominance' may be the Marxist revolution in Russia. The 'Political-dominance would be the equivalent of the ruling class the tzars and the aristocrats vs the peasants.
Jesus foresaw the new Kingdom of one of Justice and Compassion. I suppose that Marx's saw it in terms of some type of economic equality (I'm no expert on Marx so happy to be shown wrong).
Moving on I can see that Jesus 'Kingdom of God' is almost a template or archetype for most revolutions. It would seem to me that historical revolutions attempts at bringing in parts of 'The Kingdom of God', yet they eventually fail.
It makes me wonder even though Jesus spoke of the 'Kingdom of God' here and now. How did he see it running? I don't think he ever envisaged a democracy, communism or any other political system. I don't think it would have been some peace loving type hippy commune either; or maybe he did?
Thursday, April 26, 2012
The Story of Bill Gates the wealthy young man
I suspect that the scales in Western Church have tipped at least the argument to me seems scuewed towards belief in a "blind faith" where a belivever has to overcome the miraculous such as the virgin birth, miricles, the resurection etc etc to be a believer.I find it easy to understand unbelief in terms of the rich young ruler who has kept the law, but will not give away his riches and follow Jesus. Of course, it’s not an issue of evidence or even belief at all; it’s an issue of commitment and sacrifice. If the reason most people were not Christians was because they were not willing to give up things and follow Jesus, then it would make sense to me. Jesus’ demands are huge; his path is narrow.
During our holiday I had a conversation with a Christian who said that he didn't think you could be a Christian without belief in the resurection quoting Paul. My standard reply now is : I don't know and I don't think it matters.
You have to unpack belief; Do you belive the that the message behind the resurection is true? Yes I do, there is truth in the story and new life. Do I belive that they really happened. Truthfully I don't know.
Marcus Borg has a bit to say about this in his book "The heart of Christianity" CH2
Ulitmatley I don't think it matters because I agree with Nathan in the above quote. The Church has more to loose without 'commitment and sacrifice' compared to evidence based belief.
Nathan touched on Bill Gates in his blog, and I couldn't help but think of him. Comparisons between him and the biblical 'Rich young man' are hard not to make. (Mathew 16: 19-30)
I'm sure he would be an 'evidence' type of guy messing around with computers so much of his life. What he gives away is phenominal, and he gives it away in a smart way; you just have to listern to him on TED. I think his comitment is there.
But who can know the Heart....
Friday, March 23, 2012
Marcus Borg, The Heart of Christianity, The heart of the matter
Marcus Borg, The Heart of Christianity, The heart of the matter
The last chapter of the rough summaries of my readings of the Heart of Christianity::
Borg asks the question what does it mean to 'love God with all your heart' the response is '"Practice". Loving God means paying attention to God and to what God loves"
Western Christianity has not made practice central as opposed to other religions. Borg gives two reasons
- The reformation: We are saved by "faith not works".
- Western Christianity has become more about belief than knowing God.
Purpose of Practice
Practice is about:
- Paying attention to God:: intentional and thoughtful
- The formation of Christian identity and character. The aim of deepening and transformation of character of self.
- Nourishment, it happens two ways often corporately as well as individually with devotional practices
- Compassion and Justice: "ethical fruits", becoming passionate about what God is passionate about
- living the way: "Being born again, opening the heart, dying to an old identity and being born into a new identity; and becoming passionate about God's passion, the life of compassion and justice in the world."
- (Gee I like this list, no mention of recruiting!)
The there are the practices "plural"
Being part of a Church,
- it nourishes you and stretches you. (There is some really good advice regarding choice of Church)
"Participation in worship is vital for Christian Formation. In worship, we internalize the tradition through liturgy, hyms, scripture readings, and preaching."
Prayer
- Prayer is central,
Borg goes out of his way to explain how he prays for petition and intercession even though he does not belive in an interventionsist God. Very interesting!
- Intercessional and petitional language feel natural; a natural way to speak if caring.
- Borg believes that these prayers have an effect; he affirms paranormal healing
- Both petition and intercession have an underlying purpose of drawing one closer to God
Meditation
"..reflecting on an image or phrase, sitting with it, holding it, remaining with it"
Contemplation
Internal silence. To sit with God. Usualy involves a mantra.
Daily discipline
A daily practice for prayer or Christian reading. Time each day set aside for God
Practices in the Dailiness of Life.
Remembering God in the course of the day/week, prayers or rituals.
Practicing Compassion and Justice
Compassion and Justice are God's passion, In imitating God we also participate in compassion and justice.
"Justice askes"why are there so many victims" and then seeks to change the causes of victimisation" Thus the Church and Christians are to be political in seeking social transformation.
And thus here ends my book reading and rambling thoughts of 'The Heart of Christianity', great book, not many theological books I can say I've read twice 5/5.
Thursday, March 22, 2012
Marcus Borg, The Heart of Christianity, Sin and Salvation
I continue my jaunt through Marcus Borg's 'The Heart of Christianity"; the next chapter is 'Sin and Salvation'.
This is an interesting chapter as I am under the belief that we all have within us the potential to do wrong. Sin if you like. You just have to look at corrupted nations where ordinary soldiers without thinking where complicit in extermination, torture and other horrid things to people. The other thing which I can apply to myself; I can have a tendency to take the easy way even if it hurts other people, even if I don't know it. Now what does Borg say, a few thoughts
Sin
- Sin and the language of forgiveness dominates Christian 'imagination' it is 'central'. See this in the service and liturgy. Borg writes that basically you could some up that 'Something is wrong'
- Borg takes three definitions of root sin:
- Niebuhr: "hubris" or "pride"
- Tillich: "estrangement"
- Unfaithfulness
(I could relate to 1 and 3 but I've never had that feeling that 'God' has left me or vice versa)
- Borg believes Christinity would be beter off to use lots of biblical images for the 'human condition' other than just 'Sin'. Eg 'in exile, blind, lost, self-centered, wounded, sick, paralyzed. In using multiple images it also expands the remedy instead of just 'forgiveness'.
- One of the other reasons that Borg preferes using multiple images for the human condition is that. The use of sin emphasises 'individual sin' as opposed to 'social sin' (In college the term I herd was 'structural')
Salvation
- "Salvation" like "Sin" is loaded and has multi-layers
- Salvation is overly emphasised with the afterlife:: As such a requirement of who is in and who is out. (Borg is not keen on this)
- Salvation is emphasised in the Bible for this life. OT there was no clear affirmation of an afterlife until Daniel. Previously Israel didn't believe in an OT (I wonder what Borg thinks of the term Sheol?)
- By the time of Jesus the Jewish majority believed in and afterlife
- Jesus belived in the afterlife but didn't talk about it much
- Borg writes that 'Salvation' is primariy a 'this world' experience. Broadly it is about "Wholeness" to be healed. Borg also gives a list of images of salvation found in the bible eg "Light in our darkness", "Liberation for captives", "food and drink" etc.
- There are also "Macro stories" of salvation eg the exodus from Egypt, exile in Babylon.
"Strikingly, but not suprisingly, the New Testament understanding of Jesus correlates with the macro-stories of the Hebrew Bible. Thus the storie of Jesus beocmes a story of salvation."
- Salvation is personal as well as Social. Salvation is often presented for the individual but there is also of the social a "peace and justice within the community." (I'm suprised there isn't even hinted at an 'Environmental element to all of this)
Salvation and reponse:: quoting Desond Tutu "God without us will not, as we without God Cannot" As Christians we need to be an active part of the transformation.
Sin, Salvation and Repentance.
- repentence, sin and salvation are usually all clumped together
- Repent is mainly 'resolve' not primarily "contrition". A returning to God.
- Repentence in the New and Hebrew Bible are esentially the same.
The Afterlife
- I found it interesting " I don't have a clue about what happens after death";(An amazing admission. I have had a friend who read this book and this section absolutely spooked him!)
- Borg writes of the history belief what happens wtih life after death for Christians, it has been varied.
- Borg ends the Chapter with an admoinismnet of 'hope', even if he is unsure of an afterlife.
Thursday, March 1, 2012
Marcus Borg, The heart of Christianity, Thin Places,
Marcus Borg, The heart of Christianity, Thin Places.
A Few rambling thoughts and summary again on this book...
::The heart had a lot more metaphorical meaning when the bible was written than it has today. "The heart is an image for the self at a deep level, deeper than our perception, intellect, emotion and volition."
::The Closed heart ==> A human condition where the person hardens themselves, separate us and them.
:: Thin Places ==> Comes from Celtic Christianity, "...this way of thinking sees God, "The more", as the encompassing Spirit in which everything is. God is not somewhere else but "right here.". Thin places are where we actually see God ; We experience God in the world around us. (I really like this, a very strong resonance)
- Can be geographical, Borg mentions the island of Iona. (mine would probably be Wilson's promontory.)
- Arts, including music, poetry etc
- Serious illness, suffering and grief can become thin places (I've experienced this in palliative care)
- People can be thin places. Some people we can feel the presence of the Spirit upon them.
Thin Places and Christian practices
Worship in during Church is primarily a ' A thin place'. I liked Borg's answer to God requiring our 'worship'.
"I recall hearing a radio preacher talking about how "God just loves to be praised." He made God sound like a narcissist. Rather, worship has the power to draw us out of ourselves. Worshop is directed to God, but is in an important sence for us"
Other parts of a Church service which can be a thin place include
- baptism and the Eucharist
- sermons
- The bible
- liturgical words (lords prayer is a great example)
- prayer
The open heart
"The Christian life is about opening our heart to the Thin places". I say "amen" to that.
This was one of my favourite chapters. It explains why I want to seek God out. How the "thin places" give me a sence of peace. One of the blurbs on my blog is "looking for signs of beauty and redemption in the here and now". It is in many ways a prayer for the "Thin places".
Wednesday, February 29, 2012
Marcus Borg, The heart of Christianity, The Kingdom of God
Marcus Borg, The heart of Christianity, The Kingdom of God
Continuing my random thoughts and summary...
This chapter 'The Kingdom of God' has a strong emphasis on Justice. Many authors have written about this lately. Those which I have read are Brian Mclaren and Tom Wright. For me it was a massive shift when the Kingdom of God was associated with 'Signs and Wonders' to an abnormal degree, when I was in the Vineyard.
Borg writes for of reasons justice has not been emphasised because::
- Christianity been the dominant religion for so long meant the political message of the Kingdom became mute.
- 'God's Justice' has been misunderstood. "Theolgically it is seen as the opposite of "God's mercy", "God's Justice" is understood as God's deserved punishment for us for our sins, "God's mercy" as God's loving forgiveness of us in spite of our guilt. Given this choice, we would prefer God;s mecy and hope to escape God's justice. But seeing the opposite of the jusice as mecy distorts what the Bible means by justice.
- Borg mentions the US but I think most western countrys there is an ethos of individualism where people are 'self-made. To the detriment of 'Social Systems' which may have grave errors in them.
Borg gives an overview of God's passion in the Bible
Hebrew Bible:: Justice goes back to the begining, Prophets where often against suffering
New Testement:: 'Kingdom of God' was the message and passion of Jesus. It has many meanings
- Kingdom of God is political, specifically for the time Jesus said these words
- Kingdoms where a real part of life 2000 years ago, most lived in Herods Kingdom, Ceasers Kingdom Jesus spoke of Kingdom of God. Kingdom of God was a theo-political metaphor.
- Kingdom of God:: Living on earth as if God was King and current rulers where not (I like this!)
- Kingdom of God was also somthing for the earth, and what was happening on earth. Not about heaven as often been assumed. Borg writes 'Among the reasons is a linguistic decision made by the author of Mathew. He freferred to avioid using the word 'God', presumable for reverential reasons. (Not sure this is a stong argument).
::Christians had a very negative view of the current kingdom 2000 years ago, can be seen very well with Revelations.
::The Cross, not only does it reveal a path to personal transformation also it also afirms Jesus vision of the Kingdom on earth and against ingrained stuctural issues in society.
Meaning for us now
::The message of the Kingodm of 2000 years ago is the same as today, we should rail against corrupt and poor systems.
::The Church has a role in making aware of poor governmental systems.
Borg's conclusion was somthing which I thought made good sense::
Conservatives has overemphasised person transformation over the message of the Kingdom. Liberals have been the opposite, emphasising social transformation without the Spiritual transformation. "What we see in Jesus and the Bible answers our deepest personal longing, to be born again, and the world's greatest need the Kingdom of God. "
Thursday, October 20, 2011
The Meaning of Jesus, two visions, by Marcus J. Borg and N.T. Wright
The Meaning of Jesus, two visions, by Marcus J. Borg and N.T. Wright
This book is a contrasting of Christian positions by two of the leading scholars N.T Wright on the conservative side and on the liberal side is Marcus J. Borg. Interestingly I would not call either as representatives of the 'Liberal' or 'Conservatives'. Borg represents 'progressive Christianity' which has elements of liberal thought. While N.T. Wright is a bit of a radical within 'evangelical' circles. Never the less both have very contrasting positions which in itself is useful for learning and understanding.
Borg's position calls into doubt traditional Christian orthodoxy, through what he calls pre and post Easter. Post Easter is when the Bible is written. Often by people who had never meet Jesus and often decades after Jesus death.
With the 'Post-Easter' story, Jesus has started to take on a story of its own, which is different from the 'Historical Jesus'. The Post-Easter story now contains myth and is flourished with exaggeration of the true story which happened 'Pre-Easter'. Much discussion occurs about the reliability of biblical sources and the quest for the 'Historical Jesus'. A very important question for all Christians and those interested in Christianity.
Interestingly Borg does not argue with Jesus been the 'Messiah' or any other terms which has been given to him after the 'post-Easter' period. What he writes which is important during the 'Post-Easter' period is that Jesus became and is becoming the 'Messiah'. In other words; was Jesus the Messiah 'Pre-Easter?' No. Was Jesus the Messiah 'Post-Easter?' Yes.
I found Borg's writing on the 'Truth' and of Biblical accuracy of the Biblical text interesting. Much of the argument boiled down to the historical factuality of the Bible. Borg writes:: 'The issue, rather, whether the truth of a gospel story is dependent upon its being grounded in a particular historical event. Tom says "yes" and I say "No". This can pretty much sum up much of the books and its argument.
I think as time goes on Borg's position will become stronger. Time in my opinion does blur things.
I found N.T Wrights contextualisation of the political nature of the times when Jesus was alive, inspiring. Jesus portrayed as a political revolutionary. Wedged between the Roman powers and his Jewish heritage.I can see many modern day examples of this with Australian Jarrod McKenna and American Shane Clayborne.
Overall well worth reading. It helped me sharpen my own thoughts, as well as give me a greater understanding for both liberal and evangelical positions on the Gospels and Jesus.
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
Marcus Borg, The Heart of Christianity, Ch 5, Jesus the Heart of Reality (Part 2)
The second part of the chapter involves the theology of the Cross; which I thought needed a post by itself.
Borg doesn't deny Jesus execution. He believes that the reason for it was primarily because Jesus of 'his Politics- a passion for God's justice'. Where Borg differs radically from Evangelical scholars is the how the 'post-Easter' early Christians interpreted his death. One of the most well known is the 'atonement' theology'; 'Jesus died for your Sins'. Borg finds Atonment theory problematic
...atonement theology doe not go back to Jesus himself. We do not think that Jesus thought that the purpose of his life , his vocation, was his death. His purpose was what he was doing as a healer, wisdom teacher, social prophet and movement initiator. His death was the consequence of what he was doing, but not his purpose.
....Jesus kept up what he doing even though he knew it could have fatal consequences.
Borg summaries five differnt interpretations of the Cross which scholars have had through the ages.
- A 'Regection-and-Vindication understanding of Good Friday and Easter'. Authorities regected Jesus but God Vindicated Jesus. This understanding stays the closest to the political message.
- The 'Defeat of Powers' , again this is close to the political message of Jesus. Not only is it against the Romans and aristocratic rulers (I presume aristocratic rulers he means the Jewish ones of the time) Borg refers to Walter Wink as the 'dominion system which is built into human institutions.
- The Cross as 'the way'. To die to old ways and raised in a new ways of been.
- A revelation of Gods love for us.
- Lastly the sacrificial system where Jesus died for our sins. Borg writes that
..."Jesus died for our sins" was originally a subversive metaphor not a literal description of either God's was purpose or Jesus vocation. It was metaphorical proclamation of radical...
It is interesting to reflect that at certain times I have had an understanding of the first four mention. Yet the last, the sacrificial system I've previously looked at as literal. Borg's understanding has been a revelation to me. I like his understanding 'Jesus is a metaphor for God', and in many ways looking at Scripture through this grid.
Friday, September 2, 2011
Marcus Borg, The Heart of Christianity, Ch 5, Jesus the Heart of Reality
One of Borg central tenants of been a Christian is Jesus. But how he understands Jesus is quite different from a typical Evangelical/Pentecostal understanding.
Borg makes the claim that Christianity is unique in that it reveals God through a person Jesus. While in other religions this is found in the Torah or Qur'an.
Borg has five reasons why he believes seeing Jesus with a new paradigm matters.
- The historical-metaphorical approach matters because a Jesus and the Christian life based on literalism are 'unpersuasive' to many many people. The historical older paradigm emphasizes the literal and the unbelievable which goes with it.
- The importance of a Pre-Easter and Post-Easter Jesus.
- Pre-Easter is before Jesus Death
- Post-Easter is after his death or 'what Jesus became' after his death. This is important and something which I hadn't really thought about before. Post-Easter his disciple and ourselves continue to experience Jesus even after his death.
- One you get your head around the pre and post Easter Jesus they have a profound effect on how you understand the Gospels. Some of Borgs conclusions are::
- The Gospels are a continuation of the Post Jesus Tradition witten decades after Jesus actual death.
- Gospels have two stories, the pre Easter Jesus and then other traditions and understanding of the community afterwards.
- The historical-metaphorical approach matters because it helps with our understanding of Christological language.
- The last and fifth reason the historical-metaphorical study of Jesus matter is because in Jesus we get a glimpse of what a full life of God is like. Borg gives us what he thinks with a fair bit of certainty to be what we know of Jesus Pre-Easter. (Much of what Borg writes about the historical Jesus can also be read in Dominic Crossan's book 'The Historical Jesus', both have very similar ideas even if the terms they use are different)
- He was a Jesus Mystic, who had 'vivid and typical frequent experiences of God.
- He was a healer. Healers were also found in Jewish history.
- He was a wisdom teacher, 'they teach a way, a path, a life'
- He was a social prophet, much like many of the Old Testement historical figures
- He was a movment initiator, a movment came about because of his life.
Friday, July 8, 2011
Marcus Borg, The Heart of Christianity, Ch 4, God the Heart of Reality
Borg makes an important point initially in the Chapter; to be called a Christian you need to accept the reality of God. He then points out an amazing statistic 95% of Americans believe in God while in the UK this figure is 35%! (Makes me wonder what it is in Australia, probably closer to the UK).
Borg talks about world view and then two concepts of 'God'; these are
- Supernatural Theism :: God as 'person like', with a person like being there is a separates, between God and the world. God as 'up in heaven', 'out there' beyond in the Universe. The clearest expression of this according to Borg is with Paul's writing.
- Pantheism:: God and the world relationship is different. 'An encompassing Spirit'. The universe is very much entwined with God. Pantheism does not speak of divine intervention as as Supernatural Theism rather a God of divine intention and divine interaction.
Panentheism does not deny the efficacy of such prayer. Its framework allows for prayers to have effects, including prayers for healing. It does not rule out extraordinary events. But it refuses to see efficaious prayer or extraordinary events as the result of divine intervention. It does so for more than one reason. Intervention counters its notion of God: it does not see God as absent, but present. Moreover, it sees the notion of divine intervention as having an insuperable difficulty: if God sometimes intervenes, how does one account for the non-intervention? Given all the horrible things that happen, does the notion that God ever intervenes make any sense?
(This above paragraph was a light going off in my head. Many of problems that I inherently had with Christianity disappeared. Especially in the light of suffering in the world and praying for it.)
Borg goes onto write some of the issues regarding supernatural theism many of which I agree with
- most westerners only have this as the only worldview of God.
- Panentheism is just as biblical as supernatural theism if not more.
God as personal has difficulty with a Panenthiesm view of God it is much more suited to a Supernatural theism. Though whatever God is like we still have to interact with him which becomes personal because that is what we are. I get the impression that Borg has not yet acquired the language or able describe how a 'personal' panethestic God interacts. He discusses the word 'Transpersonal' "more than personal"
The Character of God
Borg starts off writing that the Character of God shapes our faithfulness as well what the Christian life is about.
Basically you could sum it up as Law vs Grace. That the Church although might point to Grace but it traditionally leans in the direction on Law. Ultimately Gods Character is one of grace and love.
Monday, May 9, 2011
Marcus Borg, The heart of Christianity: Ch3 The Bible The Heart of Tradition
In this Chapter Borg affirms the place of the Bible in Christian tradition. Borg writes that the way the Bible is treated, as infallible has cause many to question and even leave the church and Christianity. Borg suggests three adjectives as an alternative to Biblical literalism these are historical, metaphorical and sacramental.
Historical:
- This is the easiest for me to grasp. 'The bible as a product of the ancient Israel's and the early Christian movement.
- Through human authors during these two periods it was there response to God
- It reveals God in there everyday lives.
- Not 'absolute truth' or 'God's revealed truth' Rather relative truth to the authors time and place, how they saw things.
- When the Bible is approached like this issues such as the conflict between science and faith disappears. Laws of the bible are not seen as laws of all time, eg the difficulties of Leviticus.
The Holy Bible is a result of historical process not due to its 'divine origin' It is sacred due to its status and function.
To be a Christian means that the Bible is foundational to our identity and vision.
Illuminating Power of Historical Function
The new paradigm uses a 'historical-metaphorical' interpretation.
Historical- The historical context is of utmost importance. What the words means for the community it was originally written for.
Truth as a metaphor- 'a more than literal meaning of language'
[This really stuck me as a way that I could re-read the Bible, certainly it has enlightened the way I read scripture and apply it for myself. Interestingly when people use illustrations in there sermons they are actually using the 'metaphorical approach']
Borg goes onto briefly suggest the major reading of Scripture using a metaphorical approach. One example of which there are a few.
'The story of Gentile wise men coming to the birthplace affirms that Jesus is the light not only for Israel but for all nations, for everybody, Jew and Gentile'
A major point that Borg makes is that the metaphorical interpretation is beyond just a historical factuality.
The Bible as sacrament.
This way of seeing the Bible I had not really come across before, and I could imagine myself thinking it was some sort of Catholic thing. I think it is important see Borgs definition of 'Sacrament', as once you read it you can see how the Bible is a Sacred.
'... a finite, physical, visible mediator of the sacred, a means whereby the sacred becomes present to us. A sacrament is a vehicle or vessel of the sacred'
Wednesday, April 20, 2011
Marcus Borg, The heart of Christianity: Ch2 Faith the way of the heart
The heart of Christianity: Ch2 Faith the way of the heart
This chapter starts by defining how most people inside and outside the Church define 'faith' : 'believing a set of Christian beliefs to be true.' To be a Christian there is a need to affirm the 'right' beliefs to be true. This form of beliefs turns belief into a head matter instead of a heart matter.
Borg goes onto mention four meanings of faith::
Faith as Assensus: faith as belief as just mentioned. A recent phenonemon with the advent of enlightenment and beyond. What happens is questionable things are true. Doubt
I like what he writes latter on in the chapter about Assensus, 'We cannot give our heart to something that our mind rejects'
[Comment, after reading this It gave me great clarity of my own life, I had been looking for the assensus and bypassing my heart, occasionally the heart was touched but not often.]
Faith as Fiducia: Instead of believing in a set of propositions about God, it is just trust in God. Borg an illustration from Kierkegaard 'faith is like floating...If you struggle, if you tense up and thrash about, you will eventually sink. But if you relax and trust, you will float.
Faith as Fidelitas: faithfulness or even better fidelity. Not faithful to some sort of doctrine or creed but to God. A faithfulness to God and also what God loves.
Faith as Visio: A way of seeing the whole, seeing it as 'what is', nourishing, bringing us into existence and a giver of our abstinence. Filled with beauty and at times 'terrible' beauty.
The way that I look at it as 'If all things turn out for the best' and a trust in this.
[comment:: This for me Vissio is the most difficult to understand, I'm still not sure I get it.
This part of the chapter was a bit of a revelation for me. One of my constant struggles was with faith as 'assensus'. I think if people had an understanding of these broader definitions of faith then the amount of 'doubt' would be reduced.]
Borg dosn't write that we need to eliminate altogether the idea of assensus; it is still a very important part of what it means and defines Christianity to be. Borg gives his own broad 'Assensus' of what it is to be a Christian these are::
Being a Christian means affirming the reality of God
Christian faith means affirming the utter centrality of Jesus
Christian faith means affirming the centrality of the Bible
[Comment: I like the broadness of this, it is what I can affirm]
-Borg goes onto discuss the word 'Credo' the giving of ones 'deeper self' not just intellect.
-premodern understanding of faith is a relational understanding of Christian life.
I like the last paragraph it sums up what it means to be a Christian
...the central meaning of faith. Given the premodern meaning of "believe," to believe in God is to belove God. Faith is about beloving God and all that God beloves....'
Wednesday, April 13, 2011
Marcus Borg, The heart of Christianity: Ch1 The heart of Christianity in a time of Change
Over 2010 I picked up Marcus Borg's 'Heart of Christianity' in the local library. It was a book which was perfect for me at the time. Usually though with any book that I read I scribble all over it, a way for me to interact with the text. Due to the it been a library book I couldn't do this. So I'm re-reading the book and this time interacting with summaries some of the main points of each chapter....
Marcus Borg, The heart of Christianity: Ch1 The heart of Christianity in a time of change.
This chapter looks at what is at the 'heart' of Christianity and reflects on some of the major contemporary conflicts such as::
- Ordination of women
- Gays and lesbians
- Christian exclusivism
These are very serious issues which if you are in Christian or in Christian leadership you need to work through. I don't think it is good enough to just to say, my pastor told me or its in the Bible. For me the last two have been particularly prickly for me...
Borg goes onto say that Christinity is going through a paradigm change. He writes about two paradigms::
The earlier Paradigm::
- Grounded in the authority of the Bible.
- Bible as divine
- A literal interpretation
- faith as believing is central :: As Christianity has become more unbelievable due to rationality/modernism/enlightenment, the need for faith as a belief has become more important.
- afterlife is central:: A big carrot eternity
- Christian life is about requirements and rewards:: What we believe and do to get the afterlife. The minimum belief in Jesus.
Basically a response to enlightenment/modernism
Historically:: Bible written as a historical product for two communities- ancient Israel and the beginnings of the Christian community. Bible was not written for us. Historical approach emphasis interpretation of the bible.
Metaphorical:: Not interested in the 'historical factuality' rather the meaning. The stories ask not did it happen rather, what does it mean for us?
Sacramental: Something visible and physical where the Spirit become present to us. 'sacrament is a means of grace, a vehicle or vessel for the Spirit'
The first two points have changed how I read the Bible, while the last point 'sacramental' how I interact with the the world looking for things that may be a means of 'grace'
Overlap of the paradigms
- affirmation in the reality of God
- Centrality of Jesus
- Importance of a relationship with 'God as know as Jesus'
- The need for the world to be transformed.
Borg uses the words of an 'un-ending conversation' that it will continue to evolve as we interact with the Bible, our history and each other.
Thursday, February 17, 2011
Big Tent
* Carol Howard Merritt, a Presbyterian pastor, author and popular blogger on The Huffington Post;
* Brian McLaren, pastor, author of more than 20 books including A Generous Orthodoxy and elder statesman of the emerging church movement;
* Richard Rohr, a Franciscan priest, author and executive director of the Center for Action and Contemplation in Albuquerque, NM;
* Nadia Bolz-Weber, a Lutheran pastor in Denver, CO and frequent blogger for Sojourners;
* Mark Scandrette, author, teacher, activist and director of ReIMAGINE, a San Francisco spiritual collective of creativity, community building and social action; and
* Marcus Borg, well-known biblical and Jesus scholar who is now canon theologian at Trinity Episcopal Cathedral in Portland, Oregon.
Yep I reckon it would have been a ripper to have atteneded. A few of my favourite authors all in the same room. What is also amazing is that maybe ten years ago due to their beliefs I doubt meeting in the same room would ever have happened.
Related articles
- Rohr's Everything Belongs (uhsocialwork.wordpress.com)
Wednesday, August 25, 2010
Jesus the perfect way
I found this paragraph in 'The Meaning of Jesus
"...whatever these passages may have meant in their first century contexts, they need not be understood to mean that Jesus (or Christianity) is the only way of salvation. Instead , we might understand them (and similar Christian statements about Jesus being "The only way") as reflecting the joy of having found one's salvation through Jesus, and the intensity of Christian devotion to Jesus. They should be understood as exclamations, not doctrines, and as "the poetry of devotion and the hyperbole of the heart" So decisive need not mean "only"
But the claim does mean that for us, as Christians, Jesus is the decisive revelation of God, and of what a life full of God is like. Indeed I see this as the defining characteristic that makes us Christian rather than something else. If we found the decisive revelation of God in the Torah or Koran, then we would be Jews or Muslims..."
Related articles by Zemanta
- Progressive Christian, Prophetic Evangelical (beliefnet.com)
Wednesday, August 18, 2010
The Historial Jesus
Image by freestone via FlickrSome thoughts from "The meaning of Jesus, two visions
One of the key points of difference between liberal and evangelical scholars is what you can take as 'literal'. There are, like most things degrees or even aspects in which the Bible and related stories can be taken as literal.
Marcus Borg makes the point that we really don't know a lot about Jesus. What we do know of him comes from writing that occurs decades after his death. That the writing where done by his followers after his death. Where in their writing crept connections with the Telmuld and other Jewish literatuere. That during the passing on orally of the stories for decades the legend of Jesus increases by his followers. You can see this progression chronologically with Mark and the Gospels of Mathew and Luke then John.
For me it makes seems to make scene, I can actually see what he is talking about. Chinese whispers
The other option put forward by NT Wright is that the oral tradition is incredibly accurate. That the gap between Jesus death and the writing of the Gospels is nothing to worry about. Especially in a Jewish context.
Once a story has taken hold of people's minds and imaginations, it is told again and again with minimal alteration.
For me either position can be ok, ultimately a story does not need to be literal for it to contain truth! Even fundamentalists use illustration in their preaching with stories and illustrations (not in the Bible) which may not be literal but bring out the truth of the Bible.
Just to let you know I've done a review of the book which can be found on hubpages here.
Related articles by Zemanta
- Oh Jesus--I don't even know this guy!!!--coming soon (thenowandthenotyet.blogspot.com)
- "Bible scholars agree that the first gospels were written decades after the life of Jesus. Decades...." (contrararian.tumblr.com)
Sunday, August 15, 2010
Degrees of belief
This is one of my favourite quotes. From the God delusion by Richard Dawkins::
”There is something distinctly odd about the argument, however. Believing is not something you can decide to do as a matter of policy. At least, it is not something you can decide to do as an act of will. I can decide to go to church and I can decide to recite the Nicene Creed, and I can decide to swear on a stack of bible that I believe every word inside them. But none can make me actually believe it if I don’t. Pascal’s Wager could only ever be an argument for feigning belief in God. And the God that you claim to believe in had better not be of the omniscient kind or he’d see through the deception. The ludicrous idea that believing is something you can decide to do is deliciously mocked by Douglas Adams in Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency, where we meet the roboti Electic Monk, a labour-saving device that you buy ‘to do your believing for you. The de luxe moel is advertised as ‘Capable of believing thingsthey wouldn’t believe in Salt Lake City’.
It gives me an understanding why evangelism doesn't work. Some people will hear the Gosple and it just washes over them. They may understand the concepts but its something in the heart that dosn't click. They arn't been difficult, just honest.
One of the things through reading of Marcus Borg and looking seriously at textual criticism as well as looking deeper into the 'Quest for the historical Jesus" is that there are cross roads through out your walk where you have to make decisions. Did this really happen? It is for me a case of intellectual honesty. It comes back to the above quote. There are some things that you belive and can never be taken away and other well you just have to let them slide.
Related articles by Zemanta
- Humanist Hero: Douglas Adams by Frances Day (humanistlife.org.uk)
- Richard Dawkins on TED: The Universe Is Queerer Than We Can Suppose (singularityblog.singularitysymposium.com)
Saturday, July 24, 2010
Progressive Christianity :: Moving Forward
Progressive Christians believe that sacred truth is not frozen in the ancient past. While respecting the wisdom of the past, progressive Christians are open to the ways truth is moving forward in the present and future for the betterment of the world. Progressive Christianity recognizes that our sacred texts and authoritative traditions must be critically engaged and continually reinterpreted in light of contemporary circumstances to prevent religion from becoming a relic....I've become increasingly interested in 'progressive Christianity' after reading Marcus Borg.
Thursday, July 22, 2010
Paranormal healing :: Marcus Borg
Currently I'm reading The Meaning of Jesus. Two Visions, by Marcus Borg and Tom Wright.
It is interesting how for a scholar, Borg is usually put in the 'liberal' side of theology. Yet he does not deny the existence of the healing and exorcism. He calls it 'Paranormal healing' and steers well away from the word 'miraculous'.
He uses the word 'Paranormal' for two reasons
1) It is not superatural intervention, the 'miraculaous'. It thus avoids the issue of why God heals some and leave others to suffer.
2) He does not believe it to be 'psychosomatic', (I believe most 'miracles today inside the Church are in this category)
In common with the majority of contemporary Jesus scholars, I see the claim that Jesus performed paranormal healings and exorcisms as history remembered. Indeed, more healing stories are told about Jesus than about any other figure in the Jewish tradition. He must have been a remarkable healer.
I look forward to how Borg looks at the resurrection...
Thursday, July 15, 2010
Faith
The Hebrew word for faith in the Old Testament is emoonah. What makes that word interesting is that it’s the sound that a baby donkey makes when it is calling for its mother. To appreciate that, you have to say emoonah so it sounds like that.…I sometimes think to myself, if you say it soft, it’s almost like braying. The point being that faith in the Hebrew Bible is like a baby donkey calling out or crying for its mother. There’s something kind of wonderful about that. There is an element…I don’t know if you want to say of desperation in it or not, but there certainly is an element of confidence also that the cry will be heard.
What I really want to emphasize…are the four meanings that faith has come to have in the Christian tradition. The first of these four is, I am convinced, a modern distortion, even as it is probably the most common meaning on the popular level. The other three are ancient and traditional and wonderfully complementary. You can have them all, but let me begin with the modern distortion.The modern distortion of faith is the one I think I learned growing up around the middle of this century. Faith as believing. Faith as believing the doctrines of the Christian tradition, faith as believing that there is a God, faith as believing that Jesus is divine, faith as believing that Jesus died for your sins, faith as believing that…and then fill it with almost anything. Faith as believing certain statements to be true.
There are a number of reasons why I say that’s a modern distortion. First of all, try to imagine what faith was like before the Enlightenment, that great period of Western history that began in the 17th or 18th centuries. Prior to the Enlightenment, in Christian culture of the Reformation or the Middle Ages and so forth, nobody had any trouble believing that the Bible came from God, that the Genesis stories of creation were true, that Jesus walked on the water and so forth. It didn’t take faith to believe any of that, that was simply part of the taken-for-granted understandings of people living in western Christendom. It’s only when those things started to be questioned that suddenly faith came to mean believing what otherwise doesn’t make a lot of sense to you. And faith came to mean what Bishop Robinson called some 35 years ago, believing 49 impossible things before breakfast.
It makes a lot of sense Borgs understanding of 'Faith'. The 'modern day' understanding of faith is something which I always struggled with and is easily equated to doubt. I think Borg is pushing on something which is a lot more freeing than doubt. Doubt as I've come to understand it is seasonal, but this 'Faith' is forever.






